The Best Shopify Subscription Platform for Your Program Size
By Devin Relf, Marketing Manager, Ordergroove
The best Shopify subscription platform is the one that fits the size of your subscription program. Every brand needs a platform that runs inside Shopify checkout and keeps subscribers active, while larger programs also need prepaid plans, bundles, testing on lifetime value, payment recovery, and managed migration.
Which subscription platform is best for Shopify brands?
The best subscription platform for a Shopify brand depends on how much revenue subscriptions drive and how many subscription models you plan to run.
- Launching a first offer: A lightweight subscription app can be enough for one subscribe-and-save offer on a small catalog.
- Large programs, Shopify Plus brands, and brands moving to Shopify with existing subscribers: Look for an enterprise platform with a native Shopify app that adds prepaid plans, bundles, memberships, testing on lifetime value, payment recovery, and managed migration.
- Building on Shopify’s subscription APIs: Rarely worth it. The APIs provide basic building blocks, and your team would own every feature and every change.
Ordergroove sits in the second group. This guide covers what to check at each program size and how Ordergroove works on Shopify.
SmartyPants is one example. The vitamin brand relaunched subscriptions on Shopify with Ordergroove’s native integration, made subscription the default option on product pages, and added tiered incentives. Its case study reports 130% of its 2025 recurring revenue goal, a 33% increase in average order value since launch, and 57% of customer checkouts coming from subscribers. These figures cover SmartyPants’ full program.
At a glance
- The answer: Match the platform to your program size. Growing and Shopify Plus programs need multiple subscription models, configurable incentives, LTV-based testing, payment recovery, and a managed migration path.
- The proof: BARK, Daily Harvest, and Dollar Shave Club each moved their subscriber bases to Ordergroove as part of a move to Shopify.
- The tradeoff: A store launching one offer may not need an enterprise platform yet. Choose for the program you plan to run in two to three years.
- The next step: Bring your Shopify plan, payment gateway, subscriber count, and target models to a walkthrough.
How do subscriptions work on Shopify?
Subscriptions on Shopify run through a subscription platform that connects to Shopify checkout. The platform defines the purchase options a shopper sees, such as delivery every 30 or 60 days at a discount, and creates each recurring order on schedule. Shopify handles checkout, payment capture, and order records. The subscription platform manages enrollment, incentives, subscriber changes, and retries.
Payment setup is the first constraint to check. Shopify’s help page on considerations and payment gateways for subscription products says stores using third-party subscription apps must use a supported gateway. It lists Shopify Payments, PayPal Express, Authorize.net, Adyen, and Stripe, and notes that availability depends on region and the gateway’s terms. The same page limits Apple Pay for subscriptions to Visa and Mastercard.
Which Shopify subscription platform fits each program size?
Program size is the clearest way to narrow the field. Use the stage that matches your next two to three years, not only today.
| Program stage | Typical profile | What the platform must do | Platform type that fits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Launching | One subscribe-and-save offer, small catalog | Simple setup, clear offer on product pages, basic self-service | Lightweight subscription app |
| Growing | Several offers, rising subscriber count, first incentive tests | Different offers by order count and product, tests judged on retention, cart enrollment, payment recovery | Enterprise platform with a native Shopify app |
| Scaling on Shopify Plus | Large subscriber base, prepaid plans, bundles or memberships, peak-season spikes | Multiple subscription models, LTV-based testing, retention tools, international currencies, strategy support | Enterprise platform with a native Shopify app |
| Replatforming to Shopify | Existing subscribers on another commerce platform or homegrown system | Managed migration, data freeze planning, payment method portability | Enterprise platform with migration services |
Building your own on Shopify’s subscription APIs does not appear as a stage. Those APIs provide the basic building blocks for recurring orders, such as selling plans. A subscription platform turns them into a full program with enrollment, incentives, retention, analytics, and recovery.
What should a growing Shopify brand check in a subscription platform?
Check how each platform fits Shopify’s checkout and payments today and whether it supports the program you want to run as you grow. Ask each vendor to demonstrate on your theme with your products.
| Area | What to ask | What to look for |
|---|---|---|
| Shopify fit | Does the platform work with our Shopify plan, checkout, and catalog? | A native app, one product catalog, and recurring orders placed in Shopify |
| Payments | Which gateways and wallets work for recurring orders? | Support for your gateway and the wallets your shoppers use |
| Enrollment | Where can shoppers subscribe, and can subscription be the default? | Product page, cart, and post-purchase enrollment |
| Subscription models | Which models work out of the box on Shopify? | The models on your roadmap, including prepaid and bundles |
| Incentives and testing | Can offers differ by order count, and can we test them on lifetime value? | Offer controls marketing can change, plus tests judged beyond conversion |
| Retention | What can subscribers change without contacting support? | Skip, swap, pause, and reactivate from the account, email, and SMS |
| Payment recovery | How are failed charges retried and recovered? | Configurable retries, card updating, and recovery reporting |
| International | Can subscribers in other markets pay in local currency? | Support for Shopify Markets |
Bring this checklist to an Ordergroove walkthrough to see each row on your store.
How does Ordergroove work on Shopify?
Ordergroove connects to Shopify through a native app that works with standard Shopify and Shopify Plus. It uses Shopify checkout and supported gateways for payment and places each recurring order in Shopify. Its Shopify integration page notes that brands do not need duplicate product catalogs or promotions in the Shopify back end.
Enrollment on product pages and in the cart
Subscription offers appear on Shopify product pages and, through Cart Opt-In, in the cart for shoppers who skipped the product page offer. Default to Subscription pre-selects the subscribe option. SmartyPants made subscription the default and replaced “auto-ship” language with a clear subscribe-and-save offer.
Subscription models for larger programs
On Shopify, Ordergroove supports Subscribe and Save, Build Your Own Bundle, Fixed-Bundle, Rotating, and Gift Subscriptions, Memberships, and Prepaid Subscriptions, which work out of the box on Shopify. According to BARK’s August 2025 announcement, “Ordergroove now powers every aspect of BARK’s recurring revenue,” including Subscribe and Save, memberships, bundles, and Rotating Clubs.
Self-service and retention
The Subscription Manager lets subscribers skip, swap, pause, and change upcoming orders. 1-Click Actions put skip, delay, and reactivate options into email and SMS without a login. Cancel Flows present retention offers based on the cancel reason. SmartyPants added one-click delay and reactivation to subscriber emails through the Klaviyo integration. Its ecommerce manager said the subscription reminder email “drives a lot of revenue.”
Incentives and testing
Flex Incentives set program-wide discounts, product group offers, shipping incentives, and rewards that grow with order count. SmartyPants introduced a Buy More, Save More model and found that many customers chose two- or three-month subscriptions. Experiments tests initial or recurring incentives and reports lifetime value (LTV) and lifetime revenue (LTR).
Payment recovery
The Involuntary Churn Suite retries failed payments three times at two-day intervals by default, with a customizable cadence and auto-cancel rules. Recovery Optimizer reprocesses failed transactions on an optimized schedule. Ordergroove’s Payment Agent, available for Shopify stores, runs A/B tests on retry strategies against a brand’s current setup and scales the winners. Ordergroove Agents explains how it works.
What results have Shopify brands reported?
These Shopify brands run subscriptions on Ordergroove, including three that moved to Shopify and Ordergroove at the same time.
| Brand | What changed | Reported result |
|---|---|---|
| SmartyPants | Relaunched subscriptions on Shopify with Ordergroove’s native integration | 130% of its 2025 recurring revenue goal; 33% higher average order value since launch |
| BARK | Moved to Shopify for ecommerce and Ordergroove for subscriptions, replacing two subscription platforms (August 2025) | 13 million DTC orders in fiscal 2025 |
| Daily Harvest | Replaced in-house software with Shopify, Ordergroove, and Klaviyo in a five-month migration (November 2024) | 99.9% subscriber migration success with no service interruptions |
| Dollar Shave Club | Replaced a homegrown subscription system during a move to Shopify Plus, Klaviyo, and Gorgias | Seven-figure subscriber base migrated in three days with a 99.99% success rate |
Sources: the SmartyPants case study, the BARK announcement, the Daily Harvest announcement, and the Dollar Shave Club case study.
How should Shopify brands plan subscriptions for peak season?
Plan peak season around the second order, not only the sign-up spike. Ordergroove’s Holiday Subscription Report, based on Groove Network data from BFCM 2025, finds that the median enterprise brand sees a 33% lift in subscription enrollment during BFCM and only 1 in 4 brands roughly double it. For the median brand, 33% of a BFCM-acquired cohort is lost between the first and second order, compared with 28% of an everyday cohort.
- Show the offer where intent appears: product pages, the cart, and email.
- Reward the second order: use incentives that grow with order count instead of one deep first-order discount.
- Make delaying easy: give holiday subscribers a one-click way to skip or delay before the next order ships.
When is Ordergroove a strong fit for Shopify brands?
Ordergroove is a strong fit for Shopify brands in the growing, scaling, or replatforming stages. Common signals:
- A Shopify Plus or high-volume store with a large or growing subscriber base
- Plans to add prepaid plans, bundles, rotating clubs, or memberships
- A need to test incentives on retention and lifetime value
- Material revenue lost to failed payments
- A replatform to Shopify that includes existing subscribers
- A team that wants strategy support and a Customer Success Manager
SmartyPants chose Ordergroove partly on a recommendation from sister brand OLLY, which its ecommerce manager said “spoke really highly of Ordergroove, in terms of both the capabilities and the hands-on service.” A store launching its first offer may find a lighter app enough for now.
Frequently asked questions
Should a small Shopify store and a Shopify Plus brand choose the same subscription platform?
Usually not. A small store launching one subscribe-and-save offer can start with a lightweight app. A Shopify Plus brand with a large subscriber base, several subscription models, or plans to test incentives needs an enterprise platform with a native Shopify app, such as Ordergroove, that adds prepaid plans, bundles, memberships, LTV-based testing, and payment recovery.
Does Ordergroove work with standard Shopify and Shopify Plus?
Yes. Ordergroove’s Shopify app works with both. It installs from the Shopify App Store, uses selling plans and Shopify checkout, places recurring orders in Shopify, and supports Shopify-native SSO and Shopify Markets multi-currency.
Which payment gateways can Shopify subscription platforms use?
Shopify requires third-party subscription apps to use a supported gateway. Its help documentation lists Shopify Payments, PayPal Express, Authorize.net, Adyen, and Stripe, with availability that depends on region and the gateway’s terms. PayPal, Apple Pay, and Google Pay are auto-provisioned for Ordergroove on Shopify.
Can we move to Shopify and Ordergroove at the same time?
Yes. BARK, Daily Harvest, and Dollar Shave Club each moved to Shopify and Ordergroove together. Daily Harvest completed its full migration in five months with its agency and reported 99.9% subscriber migration success. Plan the replatform and the subscriber migration as one project with a shared cutover date.
Does Ordergroove support prepaid subscriptions on Shopify?
Yes. Prepaid Subscriptions work out of the box on Shopify. Customers pay once up front and receive several shipments over a set period. On other commerce platforms, prepaid plans need custom development.
Does Ordergroove use AI on Shopify?
Yes. Ordergroove’s Payment Agent, available for Shopify stores, tests retry strategies for failed payments and scales the ones that recover the most revenue. Its Retention Agent finds where subscribers drop off and proposes workflows for brand approval.
Next step: compare Shopify subscription platforms side by side
Once you know your program stage, compare platforms on the same criteria with our side-by-side framework for Shopify subscription platforms. To see Ordergroove on your own theme, bring your Shopify plan, gateway, and subscriber count to an Ordergroove walkthrough. Brands moving to Shopify can start with how Ordergroove migrations work.